The Economic Times: "Arthos helps its customers set realistic retirement goals" --> FREE Limited time offer: Sign Up Now
HR Zone » General Awareness » "The best and the brightest don't go into HR." This is the comment given by a Professor from One of the famous schools: Why?

2108 Views
  9 Replies

+1
Vote Vote
"The best and the brightest don't go into HR." This is the comment given by a Professor from One of the famous schools: Why?
Naga Bharadwaj
Naga Bharadwaj Picture
104 Posts
back to top
Posted 06-10-2008Reply

Hi,



This comment is given by a Professor, why? is there any specific reason. Take it as a Debate and let know ur comments on that.



Naga

Ramakrishna Varma
Ramakrishna Varma Picture
379 Posts
back to top
  Rated 0 | Posted 06-10-2008

Hi Bharadwaj - the topic headline is irresistible for any HR!!

Would like to see how this discussion would evolve...

Here is a quick guess at the answer to your question.

Because the HRs are better and brighter than the best and brightest as they are responsible for hiring and keeping the best and brightest :)

Naga Bharadwaj
Naga Bharadwaj Picture
104 Posts
back to top
  Rated 0 | Posted 06-10-2008

Hi Everyone, Already the professor got an appropriate answer to his comment (given by me).

I just want to share this with all u guys to see your reactions on the same.

I am sorry, if it hurts to anyone feelings.

Naga

Ram
Ram Picture
33 Posts
back to top
  Rated 0 | Posted 06-10-2008



A clarification - when i say he is not because of gender bias - I wanted to say i am saying he and not saying she and i dont want to sound like a gender biassed person..

Challa
Challa Picture
13 Posts
back to top
  Rated 0 | Posted 06-10-2008

Because 'the best and the brightest' cannot manage people. Mostly, the best and the brightest are introverts. They can't mingle with people. HR is not just human resources, you have to manage human relations, you have to become humour resources, you have to become highly reliable - all these qualities are some how less compared to the experts who can manage people effectively and get the things done. It is a known fact that only above average people succeed in life. Not the best and the brightest who focus on 'marks oriented education', now we need 'result oriented education' which creates leaders, not the best and the brightest in just getting marks by way of byhearting the content without understanding the concept.

Diana
Diana Picture
836 Posts
back to top
  Rated 0 | Posted 06-10-2008

we got to find out what does he mean by " best and brightest "

what are his points of view and according to him who falls into this category !?

Diana
Diana Picture
836 Posts
back to top
  Rated 0 | Posted 06-10-2008

i forgot to mention....

probably the HR who had recruited him has put this in his mind... he / she was not "best and brightest" coz after all.....he/she had recruited him !!!!


what was your answer Naga.... would u like to share it with us?!

Clementina
Clementina Picture
51 Posts
back to top
  Rated 0 | Posted 07-10-2008

Hi Naga,

I totally agree with Ramakrsihna and mr. challa, ie. the best and the brightest are not able to manage the HR where mingling is required.

Sanjay
Sanjay Picture
14 Posts
back to top
  Rated 0 | Posted 08-10-2008

I Beg to Differ with the professor and agree too ...

HR for years has been support function ar at least percieved to be so by people in and out of HR .

With rising dependence of business's on people in the new knowledge economy and ideal led business growth .....HR is evolving to the main stage function ...

New CPO, CHRO roles are going to steer the board to new realms of HR. These newer challenges and associated rewards will ger the best and the brightest.

Neil
Neil Picture
151 Posts
back to top
  Rated 0 | Posted 10-10-2008

How would he know?

What Criteria does he use to judge that?

I it's true what is he doing about it?

+1
Vote Vote
Lessnote

Recently in HR Forums

Hitesh posted a new forum topic in
06-04-2023
Arun posted a new forum topic in
15-02-2023
 
Recent (10) | HR | Both
HR | Both   1 of 10
23-09-2019
27-01-2018
27-01-2018
07-08-2017
26-05-2017
Arun
Arun
Read this topic:
Joke ####@@@####
26-05-2017
25-05-2017
03-04-2017
27-03-2017
27-03-2017