The Economic Times: "Arthos helps its customers set realistic retirement goals" --> FREE Limited time offer: Sign Up Now
HR News » What Is Your Greatest Weakness?
+33
Vote Vote

What Is Your Greatest Weakness?

Comments 59 Comments   Views 1739 Views     About 20-04-2009

Have you ever received that question in an interview? First, let me apologize. Most of us in HR who ask this question don’t even know what we’re asking, why we’re asking or what we’re supposed to get out of this question. Furthermore, candidates are usually so poorly prepared for this question that it usually defeats the purpose of asking it in the first place.


I know all of the cool people in HR think the question is bogus. They have a point but there are thousands of bogus questions getting asked daily that we never address. If you aren’t preparing yourself for this stupid question, than you aren’t preparing yourself for the other stupid questions that will come your way. It is easily one of the more common questions still asked today.


Here’s what I’ve figured out from asking this question (or being in interviews where this question is asked): If you answered the question quickly, you are either well rehearsed or you are extremely self-aware. If you can’t answer the question quickly or you give me some bullshit response, you’re either ill-prepared, not at all self-aware or a liar. Well, you’re probably all liars when it comes to this question which is why I don’t ask the question much.


Even if you don’t choose to give me a straight answer on this question, your glaring deficiencies should be on the top of your mind. No matter how good you become at anything, your weaknesses will hold you back. If you are the best salesperson in the company yet you neglect your spouse, it will hold you back. If you are the best number cruncher in the government but you can’t speak to other people without stuttering, it will hold you back. If you are a great speaker but you can’t ever execute a plan, it will hold you back.


When important people in your organization are talking about you, they are using “but” statements. “He’s a great welder but he can’t get along with people.” “She’s a great CEO but she is a liability with the press.” Those “but” statements point to your perceived weakness.


My weaknesses are pretty simple ones:



Impatient - If you tell me I can’t do something now, I either figure out a way around you or I lose interest in it completely. Getting married has helped this immensely but I am sure my wife would say it still needs improvement.
Lacking detail orientation - Terrible weakness for a HR person in the current legal climate right? Absolutely. At my first job, I said I was good on detail orientation and simply made it happen. Yes, I have to work twice as hard on it but I can make the big picture stuff happen more quickly to make up for it.
Laid back - I couldn’t ever say this in an interview (because it would sound like BS) but my laid back attitude has definitely impacted my career negatively. Being approachable helps in HR but it is a pain when it is time to lay down the law and people don’t understand why the attitude has disappeared.

What I can say is that working on all three of these has made me not only a better employee but a better person. Which, you know, sounds corny.


Some people have advocated just focusing on your strengths and letting them compensate for your weaknesses. Unless you are wildly successful (like top 0.01%), focusing on your strengths to compensate for your weaknesses isn’t going to get you anywhere. Maintain (or slowly build your strengths) and focus your energy on your deficiencies instead.


What’s your greatest weakness and what are you doing to improve it?


Digg StumbleUpon Facebook Delicious Yahoo Buzz Twitter FriendFeed Google Bookmarks Share/Save





Enter your comment:
You may enter 500 characters
Moninder
0
Vote  Vote
Moninder 18-07-2010  
An HR can improvise on his interpersonal skills by letting people in work area to get motivated to overcome their weaknesses by helping them understand their shortcomings and subsequently polishing them to convert their weaknesses into their strengths.
Ravi
+3
Vote  Vote
Ravi 01-07-2010  
Ya! Focusing on your strenghts and letting them compensate for your weaknesses could never be the right solution, its better to focus more on the weaknesses and bring them down. By a period of time those weaknesses could become your strengths...
Chetan
0
Vote  Vote
Chetan 25-06-2010  
HR professional needs to be alert when they get so called "printed answer" to this question but on the other hand if it is taken up to understand the candidate, it could be helpful to judge a person better.
Neil
+1
Vote  Vote
Neil 16-06-2010  
"My greatest weakness is my inability to accept anything less than the best, especially from myself!"
P.K.
0
Vote  Vote
P.K. 13-06-2010  
Practically its true but sometimes interviewer cross on this also
Amandeep
0
Vote  Vote
Amandeep 05-06-2010  
its true...bt typical too.....
Komal
+1
Vote  Vote
Komal 22-04-2010  
mainly in all interview the candidates suffer from this quastion..... what is your weakness? to justified the candidate has knowledge regarding it or not... how the controll it. but as HR/ intervitaker if you asked this quations then it become comman patten and might be posible intervier already ready with answer.... asked such case study quations... like as per you in xyz case as manager what action taken by you in this way we can easily knowing his weakness, stenths and leadership power.....
aashrita
+1
Vote  Vote
aashrita 11-04-2010  
Always make this a positive answer.
nobody`s perfect
Avishka
0
Vote  Vote
Avishka 09-04-2010  
well...this was a real eye opener...thank u

Search HR News

Recently in HR News

Lessnote
 
Recent (10) | HR | Both
HR | Both   1 of 10